Amazon Kindling New Interest in eBooks?

Amazon's unveiling of their new ebook reader, the Kindle, has generated much attention in both publishing circles and in the general media.  Everybody seems to have an opinion about the Kindle.  The most recent high-profile discussion of the merits of the Amazon Kindle was a piece by Randall Stross in the January 27th edition of the New York Times.

From the beginning, Amazon has been betting that the Kindle will be to book lovers what the iPod has been to music lovers.  Whether the Kindle really catches fire (no pun intended) or lands on the ash heap of failed attempts to digitize the general book business, I do think the conversations about books that the unveiling of the Kindle have started have been profitable for both consumers, publishers, and other people involved in the book trade. 

UC Press has agreed to participate in the Kindle program, and Amazon is in the process of preparing a few dozen files for inclusion as downloadable ebooks for the Kindle reader, so we don't currently have a big stake in this.  But from the media attention that's been lavished on this homely little ebook reading device, one would think that the future of the book business hinged upon its success.  Is it all hyperbole?

From the time I first saw a prototype of the device, I had my doubts that people would want yet another gadget, let alone an expensive gadget, in order to read digital books.  This is, unfortunately, a limitation of today's digital book reading technology.  The very technology that currently makes digital books more readable on screen, E-ink technology, requires a different display than your computer monitor, cell phone, or PDA use.  Indeed, Joe Wikert of John Wiley and Sons recently blogged about this on the Teleread ebook blog, positing that the ideal gadget for reading digital books would be a laptop that is somehow e-ink enabled.

Ultimately, though, Randall Stross's piece in the New York Times, spends less time discussing the technology behind the Kindle and more time discussing how the fate of reading book length treatments of anything in this country might be joined at the hip with wider adoption of electronic reading devices.  The book industry (it has been pointed out many times before) is one of the few entertainment industries that has stubbornly resisted digitization.  This is partly attributable to intellectual property issues with digital books and with borrowed material contained within books themselves, which isn't so much an issue for, say, musical compositions, unless they contain tons of samples.  It's also partially attributable to a sense that a book is in and of itself an aesthetic object, and avid readers from the time they start reading beautifully illustrated, four-color children's books are brought up with this mentality.  And, well, frankly, things just don't move along very quickly in the book business.  But, mostly, readers just haven't take to reading books online, although they're increasingly reading tons of other stuff online.

While none of these things is likely to change overnight, I think that the heat is being turned up by a younger generation that is accustomed to reading on screen and wants instant gratification.  But whether ebooks are ultimately widely adopted turns on not the technology itself but whether or not avid readers (those 20% of the population who buy the overwhelming number of the books sold in this country) begin to turn to ebooks.  Gadget collectors and technophiles won't make or break the ebook business–avid readers will. It also hinges upon whether this country will continue to produce avid readers of books, and some anecdotal evidence from a recent Frontline piece on social networking suggested we might be having some difficulty in this area.

Nonetheless, Amazon is in an excellent position to deliver the goods to these avid readers.  People may argue about Amazon's use of a proprietary format and digital rights management to lock down Kindle ebooks, but for users who just want to get on with the business of reading and who don't care much about managing their ebook collections, these features make this system easy to work with.  This could be the real upside to what Amazon has done.

If the Kindle itself hasn't delivered the future of the ebook, the conversations generated by its introduction have at least given us a glimpse. 

Comments

[Annie]

As an ebook site, I love this discussion, even if it is about the media giants trouncing on my niche. However, I'm counting on the younger generation's comfort with online reading and their need for instant gratification to come to my site and download a $3.99 book at 2AM. I'm counting on people deciding that what the big publishing houses decide we should read isn't enough; that they'll embrace Aspiring Authors and E-ffordable reading. I'm counting on an amazing 3D technology, instead of boring PDF/Word documents, which makes e-reading fun, to bring them back. I'm counting on readers who'd love to feed their voracious appetites for books without taking out a second mortgage to visit often. And, I'm counting on them being willing to curl up with a laptop and a good e-book without spending $300 to $400 on a reader. Oh, and did I mention, I'm counting on "THINK GREEN... READ ONLINE" to resonate with a more environmentally concious generation.